Cairo Speech: Whose Truth Did Obama Tell? - Instablogs
Cairo Speech: Whose Truth Did Obama Tell?
Rudolf , New York: Jun 4 2009
Made Popular Jun 5 2009
United States :

Cairo Speech: Whose Truth Did Obama Tell?

A day before President Obama made the now famous speech in Cairo, I was tempted to write a piece on what Obama should tell Muslims. Than God I did not attempt that. It would have been an embarrassment.

I came across the speech while flipping the TV channels for local morning news and weather. I was standing when I got to a channel that carried the speech live. I remained standing until it ended, almost 45 minutes later.

I did not have to give a standing ovation because I was already standing. I did not have to applaud because standing ovation was superior to loud applause.

As the audience in Cairo University auditorium clapped, I could hear the silence at other ends of the world. As the audience fell into silence, I could hear the applause at other ends of the world.

I imagined two neighborhoods in Jerusalem. I could hear one neighborhood applauding while the other was in cold silence. And as soon as the silent one applauded, the applauding one went dead.

From the very beginning, President Obama said he would try to tell the truth.

From the trajectory of the applauses, you could see when he told the truth about the Muslims and when he told the truth about the Jews.

What I did not hear, which was what I would have written had I mustered the courage to attempt such a speech, was the truth about the rest of us- those who are not Muslims, Jews and Christians and have no steak in Jerusalem. The truth about what the Middle East conflict has done to the rest of the world.

“Listen people,” I would have made Obama say, “the world has wasted enough time and resources on y’all. We can no longer afford to give Israel money and arms with which they will destroy Gaza and then we go ahead to give the Palestinians money with which they will rebuild Gaza and have the whole story repeat itself again and again. Meanwhile, there is a whole lot of world’s needs begging for our attention. Y’all better sit up, shape up and behave like adults or we leave y’all to mutually destroy each other.”

Something like that. Something direct. Something harsh.

Whose truth did Obama tell?

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
Wonda L
Earth, Canada
Listening to the speech one came away with a take that more or less sits in between ”Rainbows and unicorns” analogy and that it was generally a good speech with some exceptions, a couple of which are that it was a bit heavy on the compatibility of Islam and America and that Obama ”appeared to blame Israel for the misery of the Gazans, rather than Hamas, who keeps launching wars against Israel” and by doing so he failed to put the blame squarely where it belongs
1 Stars
Deakin
Phoenix, United States
it was a great speech, but this guy's right -- we're still not respecting the class war going down in the middle east. but Rome wasn't built in a day!
1 Stars
Vi
Buffalo, United States
Just to hear an American President saying such progressive, hopeful and wise words, directly to the Arab world, is immensely heartening. The more Obama declares this sort of rhetoric of peace and calm decisiveness the harder it will be for extremists to manipulate average Joes (and Mohammeds) to their way of thinking.
1 Stars
Tomas
Atlanta, United States
I can't wait until the day when we are free of Middle East oil and we realize that our "friendship" with Israel is hurting us more than it is helping us. Then we can leave the whole region behind and focus on maintaining our own country's well-being.
1 Stars
Adir
Jerusalem, Israel
I thought it was an excellent speech. I think it would be a mistake to assume that it will "change the game" by itself. But it's certainly a step in the right direction and I hope it bears fruit.
1 Stars
Nuya Bidness
Birmingham, United States
Good post Rudolf,

:( I wish I could have been there.

I also wish that I could ask all the communities of the world..”What is the payoff in holding your grudge?”

For every action, there has to be a payoff. (example) The price you pay for going on a diet is that you have to eat less, the payoff is that you lose weight.


So what is the payoff in continuing a conflict?

It seems to me that the price you pay is far greater than the payoff. But then again I am a reasonable, rational, logical person not swayed by religion, so suffering needlessly as a tribute to a god does not equal a payoff to me.

I don’t think the president has the same payoff in mind as all the other groups involved.

What are the other instabloggers thoughts on this?
Add your Comment