In search of Prophet Muhammad’s picture
12 Star
Share This Post
Rudolf , New York: Jun 27 2008
Made Popular Jun 28 2008

prophet-muhammad_Jn6jX_18If the concept of God has any validity or any use, it can only be to make us larger, freer, and more loving. If God cannot do this, then it is time we got rid of Him - James Baldwin

One of the reasons why Children of a Retired God did not win awards was my decision to exclude the piece, In Search of Muhammad’s Picture.

Just before the Danish cartoons emerged, I had given up the fight to include the piece if that would help get the editors to agree. Though it wasn’t pleasing to the proponents, the real troubling part of that compromise was my readiness to give up that search for Muhammad’s picture.

All that changed with the publication of the Danish cartoons. I have seen the picture of Muhammad and I do not like what I saw.

That was a vindication of my argument in that piece.

Initially, the reaction that followed the publication of the cartoons irritated me. It brought me back to my original stance that the piece, In Search of Muhammad’s Picture, must be included in the book. The Muslims must present the true picture of Muhammad or others are bound to do that for them.

I do believe that freedom of speech should be an inalienable right. I do not believe that your belief gives you veto power over where my freedom ends. I fear that giving up rights over some religious taboos or political pretensions will deteriorate into censorship of thoughts.

As the wise one said, your right ends where my right begins. My right not to put up a picture of Muhammad ends where your right to put up his picture begins. My right of vigilance in pursuit of “never-again” ends where your right to deny the Holocaust begins. My right to heal my painful past ends where your right to use the word Nigger begins. Subjecting freedom of speech to a veto by fundamentalists is establishing a new path to an old bondage.

Unfortunately, the world does not work like that. Justice has continued to be screwed on its head especially in relation to things religious. “The idea of the sacred,” noted Salman Rushdie “is quite simply one of the most conservative notions in any culture, because it seeks to turn other ideas - uncertainty, progress, change - into crimes.”

For both the Christians, the Muslims and all those in between, religion is an extension of politics. The battlefront in the conflict is currently on the cultural space. In today’s world, educated men are always doubtful while ignorant men are cocksure. It is the first sign of human failure that we have not founded enough religion to give each family sufficient number of religions to ensure peace and tolerance.

Is reason as diverse as religions? Is goodness as varied as religions? If they are, are we not doomed? We hold on to religion because we discovered that we must die. If all of a sudden, we do not have to die, what use will religion be? A dead religion, like a dead sea, is a religion that is not moving – not modifying. You will know that it is dead when it is finally classified as a myth.

If you ask about the meaning of life and the answer you get does not humble you – make you pensive, peaceful and ponder, you obviously got the wrong answer. A religion is nothing if it is not love. It will not endure if it will not embrace love. The story of each religion should be nothing more than the story of that religion. It should not be the history of the world. Remove emotion from religion and you will have philosophy.

When a religion advocates the destruction of God’s ultimate creature – man, that religion is a disgrace to God. The war dance of religion is most adorable to those who cannot stand the true letters of its principles. If your life does not espouse the beauty and grace of your religion, you have essentially betrayed that religion you hold so high. As religion wears off, new moral codes come in the form of ideals like freedom of speech. Like religious ideals, they have to be sacred and self evident.

Is God seen on your face? Will God fear to step into your heart? What is your truth? What is your beauty? Can they stand along others without feeling insecure? Worldwide, the cartoonist’s goal is to intentionally ridicule its object. Can your prophet withstand ridicule? Can you?

According to Robert M. Pirsig, “You are never dedicated to something you have complete confidence in. No one is fanatically shouting that the sun is going to rise tomorrow. They know it is going to rise tomorrow. When people are fanatically dedicated to political or religious faiths or any other kinds of dogmas or goals, it’s always because these dogmas or goals are in doubt.”

For me and my Children of a Retired God, it is preposterous to think about the Nigerian, the African, and the Black race in terms of the retirement of their original gods without dealing with the forces of Christianity and Islam that instigated such. Dealing with the Christian angle is easy not because the pictures of Jesus Christ are clear but because they are easily available. But the real challenge remains in finding any available picture of Muhammad, if we discount those of a Danish cartoonist.

I wish I had known Salman Rushdie’s deduction that “a poet’s work is to name the unnameable, to point at frauds, to take sides, start arguments, shape the world, and stop it going to sleep.” If I had, I would have included In Search of Muhammad’s Picture in Children of a Retired God.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Manual Upload
Sorry, no media found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
Brajesh
Banglore, India
File Type: Image
Well, you didn't have photography in those times, did you? So all we can have is perhaps a portrait of Muhammed. It is not so hard to find one. You might have heard the uproar it caused when Wikipedia refused to remove the Muhammed pictures as depicted in Persian art of those times. I am adding one here. It says;
Muhammad prohibits intercalary months during the Farewell Pilgrimage. 17th century Ottoman copy of a 14th century (Ilkhanate) manuscript (Edinburgh codex). Illustration of Abū Rayhān al-Bīrūnī's al-Âthâr al-bâqiya.


There are two more there. You can have a dekko here.
1 Stars
Jan
Brussels, Belgium
If I am not wrong, there are many, many miniatures available that depicts Prophet Muhammad just as there are many depicting Christ and other historical figures. One needs the right place to look at. Many are in the European museums and they are authenticated. I am not saying that Muhammad looked exactly like the ones depicted in the miniatures, but we can always get an idea.
1 Stars
Sebastien
Paris, France
File Type: Image
I am surprised that you were not able to find Prophet Muhamad's picture. I did a two minute google search and found the most famous one. This was drawn by one of the Prophet's official artist whom he later threatened to execute if he goes on to show the world how exactly this agent of god looked because he didn't want to be come too famous. Those days, the use of gunpowder in warfare was used as novelty. Check the artistic creativity of the artist.
1 Stars
Kahirey
Islamabad, Pakistan
Rudolf -

It is now widely accepted that if you want to sell gutter literature throw in some Islamic issue, rake up a controversy and you have a best-seller. Perhaps you missed the trick with your earlier book.

Since you know what it takes, go ahead. In the mean time, I would like to check your bag that you had been carrying ever since your began the journey of your life. Honour and dignity that you had been carrying dropped off years back (or the authorities didn't allow you to fly out with them?). You shame none but yourself.
0 Stars
Lee
Manila, Philippines
The Western world has finally got something to irk the Islamic world. There is no doubt that people who are playing with Muslim sentiments are digging their own graves. Already Islam has overtaken Roman Catholicism. This is a grave threat that we can't overlook. We must show some more respect towards Muslims and their holy symbols.
1 Stars
Johnson Obeke
Lynn, United States
Man ! You rake up shit. This is a masterpiece of what I would call classical religious referendum. Not that I want to start up shit with my Islamic buddies, but just thinking about it, this Rudolf’s piece here made me google the ’picture’ or ’illustration’ of the Holy Founder of the Islamic faith.
I think maybe the real logic of faith will be resolved when belief and religion give way to human substantiated living,and then culture and other fudamental elements wouldnt mean a thing...and like you, Rudolf said ”We hold on to religion because we discovered that we must die.” somehow Your buddy Obama couldnt have been wrong by saying that ”it’s not surprising that some people get bitter, they cling to guns or religion or antipathy toward people who aren’t like them or anti-immigrant sentiment or anti-trade sentiment as a way to explain their frustrations.” and this could as well be politics. Though now there are some undertones stipulating his affiliation with Islam as though it is a scourge. But hey thats the bane of today...Post 9-11
0 Stars
SHAHWAR K
kolkata, India
mr...

you are not to blame...

it’s just that SANITY AND DIGNITY and other HUMAN attributes never ever played up inside you crapped up mind!

what a cliched way of hurting mass sentiments without even caring for your own co-citizens.

come on.this world is meant to be lived in and GOD is meant to be believed in.

if you want popularity, then use your creative impulses, the divine bestowing in doing something good for mankind!

why hurt others when you have not been so, and even if you are then why?

do something which makes the world remember you pleasantly, not something which gathers you scorn, even in your grave...
Add your Comment