Is Suicide the Answer? - Instablogs
Is Suicide the Answer?
Rudolf , New York: Jul 17 2008
Made Popular Jul 18 2008
United States :

Is Suicide the Answer?

He did not leave a note.

By doing so, he left many - his family, friends and colleagues at a loss as to why.

Death, in and of itself, is traumatic. Death by suicide must obviously be the most traumatic of them all.

Not long ago, I wrote a short story I called “A Long Suicide Note.” It was a twist in the typical story of a young man who killed himself when he lost out in a love quest. After writing my story, I decided to google suicide and see if I could see a real suicide note. To my surprise, I encountered a site that published real suicide notes of people who died. It was creepy reading them. The weight of their suicide notes reduced my fiction to sheer intellectual exercise.

Whatever the medical, cultural, legal, philosophical and religious interpretations of suicide is, the central theme is that those who commit suicide see it as the only option in the face of unbearable pain that could come from depression, shame, financial challenges, medical conditions, cultural circumstances, political situations and social state.

What causes pain varies from one person to another. Our tolerable threshold of pain also varies greatly. When weighed down by pain, our ability to withstand depends on the pain absolving resources at our disposal. Like car shock absolver, the one found in Mercedes is far superior to the one found in a Kia. Driving on the same road with the same potholes one feels the bumps according to the kind of shock absolver one has in the car.

Often, people who kill themselves are those who feel they could not bear the pain any longer. They feel they have come to the end of the road and the only way out is to take their own lives. But is it really the only way out? Does killing oneself provide an escape? Is there really no other way to reduce pain? Do we really run out of ways to cope with pain?

I come from Igbo society where suicide is an abomination. Someone who commits suicide is going to be buried like a dog. This is usually done by strangers as the victim’s kins are not allowed to touch him or her. That is why Okonkwo in Things Fall Apart was dumped into the evil forest despite his heroic achievements for his hometown.

While some plan their suicide, others do not plan. When they are suddenly overwhelmed by pain they act.

In trying to prevent suicide, it may be important for everyone to have a plan for the worst possible pain imaginable. Just like a fire drill is aimed at practicing what to do in the case of fire. I have told those around me that in the worst case scenario, I will move to Brazil. It will be a foreign land where I can have a new beginning, a new language and hopefully a better luck. I believe I may touch the rainbow in that Amazon rain forest. A chance that is better than death. It is my drill. And chances are that in the face of unbearable pain, I will access that option before I consider suicide.

About one million people kill themselves each year across the world with another ten million attempting suicide. In the United States, 55% of suicides that occurred in 2005 were committed with guns. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) suicides accounted for 55 percent of the United States’ 31,000 firearm deaths in 2005. Suicides typically outnumber homicides by 2:1 in the U.S. While females attempt more suicides than males, males are more likely to die from suicide. Only 12 – 37% of people who commit suicide leave notes.

Because only 22% of those who commit suicide were diagnosed as mentally ill before they committed suicide, this phenomenon deserves greater attention. It starts by asking the simple question: is suicide the answer?

It is an easier question to ask now than when one becomes a survivor.

He did not leave a note. Now I am at a loss as to why he did it?

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
3 Stars
Sasmita
pune, India
No suicide is not a solution. How can you know what will happen after death. I have heard if you go to hell after death, you are deep fried in the hot oil, for all the sins you have committed. Oh God! I don’t want to go there.
Yes, sometimes life becomes too much painful, that one is forced to commit suicide. But that is not a solution. One should not let the hope die. We should try our best to struggle more and more against the negative forces of nature.
1 Stars
G emeraldsandash.blogs..
Canberra, Australia
Hi

so - I will become a spiritual dim sim (oil cooked) if I terminate myself ? Now there’s a good reason to not do it; who would want to end up as an apertif for the Devil ?

;)
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Vikas
solan, India
File Type: Video
No suicide ...is not the answer
1 Stars
Sen
Tokyo, Japan
There is a school of thought that believes that if you agree that my life is my life then you would tend to agree the arguments that pupil might provide for his right to end his own life. Suicides may not be a good thing, but it is a viable solution for many problems.
1 Stars
Lalit
Kanpur, India
O.K., let's for a second think what goes in the minds of people who commit suicide just before that commit the act. For them it is the only way to end a situation that they are facing that had made his or her life miserable. They are the people who obviously don't think that there is anything wrong in suicides.
1 Stars
Nitesh
Chennai, India
Suicide is no answer. But it takes a lot of will power to come out of negative thoughts and fight against the factors that are driving him to such thoughts. But for some the situation is beyond hopelessness. For them suicide becomes a very tempting options. The farmer suicides in India fall under this category.
1 Stars
Ekta
Jaipur, India
Rudolf

I feel killing is killing and murder is murder : by committing the crime or invoking the death penalty, but how can an issue like this be resolved ?


I didn't understand that bit. If I kill myself can I be possibly be held accountable for my own murder? There are laws against suicide in many countries. Attempting to commit suicide can be punishable. In India it is up to one year in prison.
1 Stars
Rolande Hodel AIDSfreeAFRICA.org
Ossining, United States
Interesting, in India where wife burning is common and goes unpunished - where ”honor” killing goes unpunished as well one goes to jail for attempting suicide?
1 Stars
G emeraldsandash.blogs..
Canberra, Australia
One year in prison ? That’s funny - in a very dark way. If one is so miserable and defeated that they feel that suicide will be a solution for them - put them in prison for a year to cheer them up for trying to kill themselves. OMG. *knock knock* Hello ?
It’s incredible...

Discouraging suicide is important but punishing people in this way will surely only deepen their depression, anxiety or otherwise existential angst and not help them to try and deal with their problems calmly and constructively.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Prashant
Kathmandu, Nepal
"Only the cowards commit suicide." This is such a cliche, an universal cliche at that. I wonder how many people are there who has the courage to go the full distance. You would be surprised that most people who commit suicide or attempt them are people who just try to draw attention of others to them. Most of them don't take sure shot ways to die. They take pills, household vermin poisons or cut the arteries of the wrists but won't shoot themselves on the head or hang themselves.
1 Stars
Hey, Welcome to Brazil! (no, this is not a title)

Suicide is not the answer, but may be the only alternative. Certain diseases like depression can be very unbearable for a human being. Okay, there are remedies, but at what cost? Transforming into a zumbi is not an option.
1 Stars
I think a sect in Japan actually supports the concept of suicide. They think its within ones right to end ones own life.
Loneliness, depression and extreme situations lead to such decisions. More community groups and support groups should evolve to help people overcome their personal trauma and distract them from taking one last fatal step.
1 Stars
Suicide is not the answer. Many people who commit suicide, usually are depressed and feel forlorn; if seen from the other point of view - it will show almost for all of these people what the other person say about them is important - They refuse to look deep inside their defeat - This is what every psychaitrist should concentarte on.
1 Stars
Rolande Hodel AIDSfreeAFRICA.org
Ossining, United States
Suicide is only horrible for friends and family who are left to wonder. Who feel guilty because they did not see it coming and feel helpless and abandoned by the person committing suicide.

Not leaving a note has an easy explanation, believe it from someone who’s been there done it: There is no one left to talk to or to write to. If I had had someone to write a note to, I would have talked to that person.

And one last comment, I would do it again. There is so much peace in that moment, to know that you are in charge again, to have the power finally to remove yourself from a situation that is unbearable. Yes, I do enjoy remembering that moment.

Today, I have the say in my life and more options than 30 years ago. I also believe that we are put on earth for a purpose. To live that purpose and to give back to society using the talents we have inherited, means to honor the people who gave us life, our parents and the people who taught us, our teachers.
1 Stars
Hemant
Varanasi, India
Rolande Hodel:

Interesting, in India where wife burning is common and goes unpunished - where ”honor” killing goes unpunished as well one goes to jail for attempting suicide?


Yes indeed! I often ask the question myself every morning when I see myself on the mirror to get ready for my daily job, which is snake charming.
1 Stars
G emeraldsandash.blogs..
Canberra, Australia
OMG - you are a snake-charmer. How utterly wonderful. :)
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Ivan
Sofia, Bulgaria
Suicide is the answer is there is no answer left or there is no one you can find who can possibly give you the answer that you seek for so morbidly. This means suicide is for people without friends and that includes a girlfriend called Hope.
1 Stars
G emeraldsandash.blogs..
Canberra, Australia
Hope. Have you got her phone number ?

;)
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Jake J
Montgomery, United States
I find that everyone who says suicide is not an answer are people who have not considered it. They have good lives now, and they might even be making other people’s lives a living hell. They wouldn’t want those people to commit suicide, because then they’d have to move onto other people.
Problem is, they have no options in preventing these people from committing suicide. Suicide is a right. If I had decided to do it, and someone took my means away, that would make me extremely angry. Who are you to interfere and take my rights? Trust me, when considering someone as resourceful as myself, you don’t want to get in my way. In my anger, I’d take you with me.
That being said, I have no plans for suicide, and have much more to do before I die. Just don’t think you can go taking poeple’s rights to suicide away, because you never know what will happen to you in the process.
1 Stars
G emeraldsandash.blogs..
Canberra, Australia
The great Marcus Aurelius, stoic philosopher and emperor of Rome, believed (as many stoics of the time did) that if one felt that they had achieved everything they possibly could in life that suicide was acceptable.

This is not my view.

I have lost numerous friends over the years to this deed.

Suicide is, in most cases, a long-term solution to what are probably short-term problems.

Suicide is never the answer. It is only another question.
1 Stars
John mealercompanies.com
Show Low, United States
I commit suicide often and with glee.

Seriously Rudolph...

It’s certainly not right, but it is right enough for the people who do it and that’s all that matters.

Some people seek peace from inner demons and this is their only way to quiet the voices that torment them.

People who murder unborn babies surely do not fit the bill of decent caring people as they care only for themselves.
Only because there are plenty of people who will gladly care for the baby they murder.

I like to think of it this way, although it is sad nonetheless...

The Creator (God as people refer to the diety) is not surprised by the sudden appearance of a ”soul” for no better term. The death as it is was meant to be that exact death at that exact time.

Otherwise, a human that kills oneself would be as powerful as the Creator.

Anyhow.. Suicide stinks.
Don’t do it people because someone surely loves you!
1 Stars
Fariha Jamil
Lahore, Pakistan
”Do we chose to come into this world?”
If yes, we have all the right to put an end to ur life, but since we don’t, we dont have the right to go away from here by our own choice. The Hand which brought us here only has the right to do so.

We are the Lost Genreation, unable to find the meaning and reality of life.
There is a universal reason for creation of man and that is self realization and to discover his own being... it is beyound the boundries of any religion. Only knowing the purpose of creation can give us the right perspective of life and recuse us from depression and all other negative emotions. May God help us all!
Add your Comment